NPS vs PPF – Which one is better and basic Difference

There has been a long debate on which one is better- the National Pension Scheme or the Public Provident Fund. Lets us explore the basic differences between the two in order to clear the confusions. Below stated are 10 basic differences between PPF and NPS which define both the schemes. And yes, do let me know any other things which can be added in below provided list.



Basic difference between NPV and PPF

Hope this will clear the cloud and give you much better idea:

  National Pension Scheme (NPS) Public Provident Fund (PPF)
1. Purpose National Pension Scheme is aimed for benefit of individuals after retirement. In Tier 1, the contribution is made by the employee and the same amount is paid by the Government. For Tier 2, no contribution is made by the Government. This is an additional tax saving instrument. PPF is a government regulated scheme which is saving cum tax saving instrument and is considered to be very safe and reliable. This is a primary tax saving instrument.
3. Duration NPS is aimed at benefits after retirement which is after 60 years of age. PPF has a fixed locking period of 15 years.
4. Eligibility

 

All Indian citizens between the age of 18-60 years and who are working can apply for this scheme. NRIs are also eligible. Indian citizens are eligible for this scheme. Minors can also enrol guided by their parents or guardians.
5. Interest A maximum of 10% interest along with employer’s contribution are offered after retirement. Interest rate as well as locking period varies from bank to bank which generally ranges between 6-8.75% per annum.
5. Pre-mature withdrawals Early maturity is allowed but only 20% can be obtained as lump sum. The rest of the 80% needs to be invested in the life annuity scheme which is moderated by a life insurance company approved by IRDA (Insurance Regulatory and Development Authority) Pre-term withdrawal is only allowed after four financial year lapse.  Only 50% of the actual amount invested is allowed to be withdrawn and only once a year.
6. Tax benefits Tax benefits are offered for NPS. Addition to one the 80C Act of 1.5 lakh, additional fifty thousand is exempted from tax. Tax exemption is offered for one 1.5 lakh which is covered by the 80C Act.
7.  Investment charges NPS charges a very nominal amount of 0.250% as management charges. No management charges are levied for opening an account for PPF.
8.  Investment amount For Tier 1, you will have to pay a minimum of INR 500 as subscriber’s contribution. Contribution is allowed once a year and a minimum of INR 6000 per year.  For Tier2, minimum INR 1000 is required and a total of INR 2000 in every financial year. There is no maximum upper cut-off for contribution. For PPF a minimum of INR 1000 is required to open an account. There is no upper limit. The stipulated amount can be deposited in 12 instalments in a financial year.
9. Investment mode Investments can be made in three separate sectors, namely; equity, government securities and corporate debts. One can choose from any of the above three. In the case of equity, only 50% of the amount can be utilised to be invested. If no option is chose by the contributor, automatic involvement of money made. Loan facility is not available. There are no investment options offered to the contributor to choose from. The investment is automatic and government regulated. The investment is automatic and government regulated
10. Returns NPS is related to market risk and trends which affect the final return. PPF is purely regulated by the Ministry of Finance. Returns are precisely predictable and interest rates are declared by the Government every quarter.

Conclusion

Bott having own advantages from tax saving to investment option. However if you ask me, which one is better PPF vs NPS, then i will go ahead with PPF.

NPS is surely a good additional tax saving instrument but also has stringent pre-mature withdrawals rules, no loan facilities and involves market risks.

On the other hand PPF is very safe and predictable which also offers loan facilities from the seventh financial year. Investment in both depends mostly on the primary need and future return expectations of the contributor.

16 comments

  • pothana srinivasa Rao

    NPS is very attractive and long term given 10 or 1.0.50% return for year. It is is better than all mutual funds and Bhima and Lic plans. It is super saving and retirement plan for all citizens.

  • PRANAB KUMAR GHOSH

    sir,
    you have mentioned under INTEREST heading that ” A maximum of 10% interest along with EMPLOYER”S CONTRIBUTION are offered after retirement.’.
    My daughter is working in IT Sector (Pvt.organisation). She is contributing her PF in EPF scheme and her employer also deposit their portion in EPF. She is a member of family pension scheme under EPF. She wants to continue her EPF Scheme.
    Please suggest me whether she can,as an individual,open NPS account as additional tax saving instrument and retirement benefit without hampering her EPF contribution and without informing & taking permission from her present employer..
    —- P.K.GHOSH

  • rajendra

    please suggest me that i invest rs. 50000 per annul t hen i receive monthly pension rs. 3062 and maturity rs. 306000 approx that my query is monthly pension and maturity amount both receive me or single
    which amount receive me are tax free or taxable

    • S S Chaudhary

      please suggest me that if I invest Rs. 50000 per Annam then I receive monthly pension and 60% maturity amount one time. My query is which amount are tax free and/or taxable.

  • Arindam karfa

    1) I am salaried govt.employee.is my contribution to the fund is deductible above Rs. 150000 for tax savings?
    2) if the account is in my wife’s name; then will the contribution be tax saving?

  • Akmathur

    I am a salaried psu employee having no pension options and annual income more than 20,00,000 which option is better for me

  • Akmathur

    Give me suggestions

  • Sachin

    Which one is better to open NPS ICICIBANK or LIC pension fund.
    Kindly revert with advantage and disadvantage of both

  • JAY PRAKASH KUMAR

    I am a central gov employee.what 50000/-extra tax benefit

    • Deepesh

      If you are already not contributing into the NPS, then you can get an additional deduction of Rs 50,000 for investment in NPS under Section 80CCD(1B).
      Please note NPS is compulsory for central govt. employees who joined after 2004.
      Btw, even if you are contributing to NPS through your employer, you can still get the benefit for Rs 50,000 investment in NPS. Just that you need to contribute to the same NPS account.

  • archana

    sir i am a salaried person. I will get pension after my retirement, but if i take NPS Scheme then I can take Rs. 50000 of NPS scheme rebate besides 1,50,000/- under 80C. Kindly let me know as I feel SBI pension fund under NPS is better. Please reply soon as I have to submit my income tax details.

  • jai shankar

    sir, my question is that how much I get after 60 years of total amount? after death of depositor and how much %of remain amount will get to nominee.

  • DESHMUKH SUBHASH

    I am NRI I want to invest in this pension plan but we can give money as a dollar or in INR also we can deposit from from normal account we can beneficial or not pl suggest

  • Rohit anand

    Sir
    I am 25 I read in newspaper that if u invest in nps at the age of 25 of 2000 per month for the age of 60 year.ur total money will be nearby 12400000.
    so, please clear my confusion that is it right or wrong.if this is right then from where i will take the nps plan.please clear my dought in detail.
    Thanku.

  • Self

    Sir,
    Can a homemaker avail the NPS scheme?

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *